5 Reasons an NDA, or Part of It, Might Not Hold Up
1. The language is overly broad
If an NDA tries to stop you from discussing things far beyond genuinely confidential information — like your own general skills or publicly known information — courts often view it with skepticism.
2. It keeps ordinary information secret forever
Many NDAs set a time limit for general business information, commonly one to five years. A rule keeping ordinary, everyday information secret forever can be questioned, although trade secrets can legitimately stay protected for as long as they remain secret.
3. It covers information that was never confidential
NDAs can only protect genuinely secret information. If what you are being asked to keep quiet was already public, or is just general industry knowledge, that part of the NDA generally cannot be enforced.
4. It tries to block legally protected reporting
In the US, the Speak Out Act makes NDAs signed before a dispute unenforceable against claims of sexual harassment or assault, and NDAs generally cannot stop you from reporting possible illegal activity to government agencies. Some states add further protections.
5. There is no clear agreement
An NDA needs a real agreement between the parties. Verbal confidentiality agreements can be binding, but they are much harder to prove, which is why NDAs are almost always written and signed.
Related Guides
- How to Read an NDA Before Signing
- Did I Break My NDA by Talking About Work?
- When an "NDA" Is Really a Non-Compete
- Check Your Non-Compete Agreement →
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes an NDA legally enforceable?
An NDA is generally enforceable when it clearly defines what counts as confidential information, has a reasonable time limit, both parties agreed to it voluntarily, and it does not try to cover illegal conduct or information that was never truly confidential.
Can an NDA be too broad to enforce?
Yes. Courts often refuse to enforce NDAs that try to restrict far more than necessary, such as banning you from discussing your own general skills and experience, or covering information that was never actually secret.
Does an NDA need a time limit to be enforceable?
Not always. Many NDAs set a period of one to five years for general business information, and trade secrets can stay protected for as long as they remain secret. A rule that keeps ordinary information secret forever is more open to challenge.
Can an NDA stop me from reporting harassment or illegal activity?
Generally not from reporting to authorities. In the US, the Speak Out Act makes NDAs signed before a dispute unenforceable against sexual harassment or assault claims, and NDAs generally cannot stop you from reporting possible illegal activity to government agencies. Details depend on the agreement and your state.